Both are amazing! They both contain the major polyphenolic compound present in green tea, EGCG which is antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and antimicrobial properties. It has shown improvement in treating acne and oily skin.
The Isntree has other actives that make it great for oily skin and sebum control. And it's made of extract instead of water, so it's more concentrated.
But it can be irritating for some with sensitive skin
The Benton is milder and it contains calming and soothing ingredients, so it's perfect for sensitive skin. It's super watery and perfect for layering. I have combination (very dry on cheeks) an dehydrated skin and thsi toner is PERFECTION! I'm a huge fan an di ahve recommended it her over 2000 times.
I have both, use the Isntree on t zone an d then I layer the Benton up to 10 times on the rest of the face.
They are both inexpensive and awesome so why choose?
But if I had to, I will go for the Benton