Crusty, wrinkly eye skin

Around my right eye only, I have this crusty-looking, extra wrinkled, slightly red skin. There's also a little flap of skin folding over my eyelid. I noticed it about a month and a half ago. I started using extra moisturizer and it went away. I went back to my normal amount of moisturizer and it came back. My other eye is normal. Why could it be like this? Products I use: L'essential cleanser, toner, serum; Bliss clear genius toner+serum (not on eye area); was using Make P:rem hydrate me micro tension cream; just started The Ordinary natural moisturizing factors+HA First two pictures are affected eye, third is other eye. It's more noticeable in person.