picky logo
picky logo
Productscurationdiscussionpicky for creatorsJoin Picky Plus โž•

Product Info

theskinilivein user profile picture
picky squad user badge

theskinilivein

Oily/Sensitive

dot3,451 Views

Help me understand the difference between "white cast" and "tone up" in sunscreens ๐Ÿ™

Hello Pickies ๐Ÿ‘‹ I have seen quite a bit of promotions on social media for "tone up" sunscreens with "no white cast". But to me it seems like all sunscreens from that category do leave a white cast? ๐Ÿค” At least what I see as a white cast shows everytime the sunscreen is either swatched on the back of the model's/influencer's hand or on their face. I don't mind the "tone up" feature, but I would rather purchase sunscreens that do not leave a white cast. Could you please explain the difference between "tone up" and "white cast"? Is it just marketing or is there really a difference? Thank you for your help ๐Ÿฅฐ
upvote

201

comment

32

32 Comments

qilss user profile picture
picky squad user badge

qilss

Oily/Resilient

Tone ups are specifically made to provide a tint (usually pink, peach, beige or even lilac) that evens out and brightens the skintone. They look and blend better on the skin. Whereas whitecast seems to just sit on the skin and can be hard to blend. They also look harsher due to the white base as opposed to the soft coloured tints in tone up spfs Tone up can translate to whitecast on a lot of people because it's just too light on most skintones ๐Ÿ˜… The whitening effect is too obvious. Those who aren't familiar with the term will say it's whitecast. Tone up is intentionally thought out when creating the formula but whitecast isn't, it's like a flaw, an unintended side effect basically
upvote

60

comment

0

J

jpoz

Dry/Sensitive

This is a great explanation. I have just recently started experimenting with tone up spf. My skin tone is about as pale as possible, which makes me a little on the fortunate side in regards to โ€œtypicalโ€ whitecast. I have one that has a beautiful, perfect finish but is too drying for regular use. So as in any other skincare and ingredients, I think โ€œtone upโ€ is going to vary based in skin tone and skin condition / needs. More trial and error.
upvote

18

comment

0

uwiiii user profile picture

uwiiii

Oily/Sensitive

As far as my experience with using several sunscreen products and tone ups on my tan skin, usually if the product has a white cast, my skin color will look grayish, but tone up is not so, the tone up product only raises the skin tone slightly so it doesn't look gray, it looks bright and fresh.
upvote

56

comment

0

theskinilivein user profile picture
picky squad user badge

theskinilivein

Oily/Sensitive

That makes sense to me! But in all those promotions I definitely saw a white cast because the skin just looked white in a non natural way. Thank you for your explanation ๐Ÿ˜Š
upvote

20

comment

0

Ozu user profile picture

Ozu

Oily/Sensitive

'Tone up' effect varies according to people preferences. For me, I like sunscreen that has 'tone up' effect that can even up my skintone. I relate tone up with tone correcting. Usually I prefer one that has some pink undertone, since I like how it gives the 'liveliness' feel to my face๐Ÿคฃ White cast on the other hand, makes your skin appears to be covered with a white film. So, the skin you apply sunscreen with whitecast will seemingly to be 'whiter' that your original skin tone. It does nothing to tone correcting. Luckily for me, I have a fair skintone, so I generally don't mind any whitecast.
upvote

45

comment

0

PickyMember user profile picture

PickyMember

Dry/Resilient

thank for explaining
upvote

9

comment

0

CannijGood user profile picture

CannijGood

Oily/Resilient

Thereโ€™s always a white cast when you use spf with zinc oxide.
upvote

4

comment

0

theskinilivein user profile picture
picky squad user badge

theskinilivein

Oily/Sensitive

I am not sure about that, I use spf with zinc oxide but there isn't a white cast when I use it. ๐Ÿค”
upvote

4

comment

0

ash01 user profile picture

ash01

Oily/Resilient

here for the answersโ€ฆ have been looking for clarity in tone ups too
upvote

3

comment

0

ash01 user profile picture

ash01

Oily/Resilient

great question
upvote

2

comment

0

K-Beauty Giveaway Events

kbeauty Picky x Natural Derma Project | HA Boosting Serum & Vitamin B9 Tone-Up Cream event

Picky x Natural Derma Project | HA Boosting Serum & Vitamin B9 Tone-Up Cream

Audience

All Users

Deadline

November 22th

picky coins500
Picky app preview

Join the Picky Community

The Picky community helps you discover new products through discussion boards, honest reviews, expert articles and redeemable free product rewards. #GetPicky!